Driving long distances in an electric car is impossible, right? We tried to explain common misconceptions from the owner's point of view.

Porsche Taikan
Porsche Taycan

Usually when we talk about Taikan or Model 3, we say, "But electric cars can't run long distances, can they?It is often referred to as "the

I'm afraid that if I drive, I'll gradually run out of charge and have to stop in the middle of the road (laughs)... With gas stations, there are gas stations everywhere, so I'll be fine, but not with electricity, so I'm afraid of driving long distances."

."No, no, no, no, you wouldn't do that kind of unplanned running.I was thinking, "I'm not sure what I'm supposed to do.

It can run quite well. Both Tesla's Model 3 and Porsche's Taikan can run long distances. Our Taikan can run 370 km on a full charge, and even when driving normally from home to Fuji Speedway without thinking about the cost of electricity, we only had to charge the battery once during the 450 km one-way trip. It was a 90kW quick charge, and it took only 30 to 60 minutes. The charge is completed while I'm having lunch, and that's not a problem at all."

Although the "No, but I'm afraid of getting stuck in traffic, and I'm afraid I'll lose more and more charge. I'd feel safer on gasoline.This makes us realize that the image of electric vehicles is quite deep-rooted.

So in this article, I hope to dispel some of those misconceptions in the world (laughs).

Explanations for misconceptions about electric vehicles

Below, we would like to proceed by explaining one by one the misconceptions about electric vehicles.

(1) Short cruising range

I hear this kind of argument all the time. There are many fuel-efficient gasoline-powered cars available today, and I used to have one in my home,Mercedes-Benz GLB200dwas able to run about 700 km on a full tank, so the cruising range is indeed short by comparison.

But.As for the Taikan, it can run about 370 km on a full charge, and the Model 3 can run about 550 km.

Tesla Model 3

Previously Model 3 from Hyogo Prefecture to Toba, Mie Prefecture,We drove about 670 km round trip in the Tesla, and upon arrival at the hotel, the battery had about 501 TP3T remaining.We had confirmed in advance that the hotel where we were staying had regular charging facilities, so we charged the battery there, and by the next morning it was charged to 100%.

And on the way home, I drove without recharging the battery once and arrived home with about 20% left.

Certainly there is no substitute for a longer cruising range, but "theEven if you can run this much on a full charge, it's still not enough.I wonder if there are not many situations in which the "I'm not so sure.

In addition, electric vehicles do not lose charge in traffic jams (gasoline-powered vehicles obviously lose charge). I have heard rumors that if you are stuck in traffic in the middle of winter, the charge will decrease rapidly, but in fact, the Taikan was delivered in January of this year, and although I have experienced a fair amount of traffic jams, I have no such sensation.

In addition, electric vehicles use a regenerative energy system, which reduces the charge when going uphill, such as on mountain roads,The charge is restored on the descent.This is a mechanism not found in gasoline-powered vehicles, and even when driving over mountains, it is often the case that the battery charge is surprisingly low when the lid is opened.

(2) Lack of charging infrastructure

Comparing gas stations to charging spots, gas stations are everywhere, and the infrastructure is not adequate. However, there are currently over 21,000 electric charging spots (as of the end of August at GoGoEV), and of course, not all of them can take advantage of the various types of fast charging, regular charging, and Tesla's Supercharger, although there are regional differences,It is a feeling that is increasing quite a bit.

Image source: https://ev.gogo.gs/news/detail/1725239618/

Also on the GoGoEV website,

The month of August, which saw many natural disasters, also provided an opportunity for local governments to review their disaster preparedness. Since EVs, which can be used as storage batteries, can play an important role in disaster prevention, it is expected that local governments will promote the spread of EVs and develop recharging infrastructure as part of their disaster prevention measures.

It was written. With the government's policy of making all new cars sold by 2035 electric vehicles, I wonder if infrastructure development in this area will make progress.

In addition, the penetration rate of electric vehicles is not yet high in Japan at this time,Charging spots are often relatively empty.In my experience, I never had to wait for a recharge, especially since there are sometimes multiple recharging spots on the highway.

(iii) Inconvenient due to long charging time

Charging does not take 3 to 5 minutes, as it does at a gas station. Since Taikan's charging capacity is 90 kWh, it would take one hour to go from 0 to full with a 90 kW quick charge (although it is almost never actually at 0).

This is the only thing I see that takes time,If you charge the battery while eating lunch at a highway service area, you can finish charging the battery during that time.In addition, some parking lots in Osaka have free 200 V regular charging stations, which are almost always open, so if you charge while parked, by the time you return, you will often have recovered enough for the trip to get you there.

The gas station isI go out of my way to refuel."sense, but because we think of electric vehicles in that sense, we feel that it is a hassle. In the case of electric vehicles,Instead of going all the way, "I'll just charge it while I'm parked."That's the feeling. Just like charging your phone when you are not looking at it.

If you change your mindset, there is no inconvenience.

Porsche Taikan

In that sense.It would be quite convenient to have a regular charging facility at home, and that is exactly what we can use on a daily basis, just like charging a smartphone.If you do not have charging facilities at home, it may be a little inconvenient, but if you use a parking lot with charging facilities where you usually park when you go out, there should not be a big problem.

(4) Driving performance is inferior to gasoline-powered vehicles

Especially when I mention that I drive a Tesla.Electric cars don't drive that well, do they? They are eco-friendly, but they still run on gasoline.Many people often speak of their impression that

In such a case, "No, no, no...please tell me after you drive one. The driving experience of an electric car is really amazing. You'll be surprised.I sometimes answer with a lot of pressure (laughs).

I do not have experience with electric cars from all manufacturers,The only two vehicles that I would like to mention are the Taikan and the Model 3, and the first thing I would like to mention about these two vehicles is that they are very comfortable.

It is smooth, has no rattles (although the legs of the Taikan are stiff and may rattle depending on the road surface), and is truly luxurious and comfortable.

Stability and acceleration performance are also excellent.The instantaneous torque, unique to electric vehicles, makes the car suddenly very fast, even when merging on the highway or when overtaking a car.
In terms of the acceleration feeling of being pressed against the seat, the Model 3 is faster than the Taikan.

That feeling can never be experienced in a gasoline-powered car, and once you have it, it is addictive.As for the Taikan, it is said to have been developed with the aim of becoming a 911, and it has both the handling qualities of a sports car and the ride quality of a Porsche itself.

I prefer to drive an electric car for long distances on the highway because it rides and drives better, and it is stress-free. (Of course, it is a matter of preference.)

I just can't get this feeling from just reading the text or watching test drive videos on youtube.

You can't know unless you ride and experience it, so I hope you will give it a test drive (I am not a salesman, W).

I should have owned it sooner...!

Public misconceptions about electric vehicles still persist.

But in fact, in the last few years,Cruising range, charging infrastructure, charging time, driving performance...all of these are more advanced than we could have imagined.It always takes time for new things to be accepted by the world, but I am sure that when you own one, you will find that you will be able to enjoy it.Wish I had owned it sooner...You may often think, "I'm not sure what I'm supposed to do.

In fact, one of my acquaintances wants to drive an electric car in the near future, and I plan to give him a ride. I hope that I can convey the beauty of electric cars at the grassroots movement level.

Mina.

Mother of three children, and the owner of the Porsche blog "A Porsche Came to Our House". Until a few years ago, I was not interested in cars at all, but when my husband bought a Porsche, I became...

Profile

Follow me if you like this blog!

Close Comment
  • Comment ( 5 )

  • Trackbacks are closed.

  1. beach box

    Hi @@@@.

    非常に面白い纏めで楽しく読ませていただきました。

    僕は血液がハイオクで出来ている(自称)くらいにガソリン車好きですが笑、お二人のブログを読んでいて最近EVにも興味が出ている今日このごろです笑

    気になる点としては、バッテリーの寿命がどの程度になるのか、ですかね。こればかりは長年使わないと分からないのですが、技術の進化と共に寿命も延びていくのでしょうね。
    あとは、車として優秀なのはもはや疑いようのない事実なのでしょうが、まさにバッテリーの寿命という観点で車が使い捨てみたいなことになりやしないのかは懸念するところです。ガソリンを燃やしまくっている人間が環境云々を語るのはおこがましいですが、1台1台のライフサイクルが短くなると結局環境性能としての優秀さはどこまで認められるのか…という点も、考えてみたいですね。

    1
    • HiroHiro

      Hello, HAMABOKU.

      バッテリー寿命ですが、たとえばテスラが公式に発表しているデータによると、モデル3およびモデルYのバッテリーは、約32万キロ走行後でも容量の85%を維持し、モデルSとモデルXでは約88%の容量が維持されることが報告されています。
      日本人の多くは、初代日産リーフがすぐにバッテリー劣化した経験と噂から、スマホのようにバッテリーが劣化すると思っている人が多いのですが、現実はそうではありません。
      私のモデル3も購入後既に7000キロ以上走っていますが、現時点で99.9%以上を維持しています。


      https://www.tesla.com/ns_videos/2023-tesla-impact-report-highlights.pdf

      このようなデータから考えると、私の個人的な見解としては、EVの方がエンジンに比べて可動して摩耗する部分も少なく、オイルも不要、ブレーキを回生がメインなので負荷も少ない、
      それに加えて、これほどバッテリーが持つということを考えると、意外とエンジン車より長寿命だということが判明する未来が来るのでは?と予想しています。

      とはいえ、環境負荷で考えると私はEVだからといって環境負荷が少ないとは思っておらず、製造や廃棄のことを考えると、あまり変わらないのでは?と思っています。
      なので、EVには乗っていますが、特に環境を意識してというつもりは無く、単に電気によるモーター駆動が楽しいから乗っている感じです。

      2
  2. Model3 Life!

    航続距離と動力性能については、前車は初代リーフのイメージが強いのだと思いますし、後者はデパートの上にあったパンダの乗り物のイメージが強いのでしょう 笑

    航続距離については所有してみないと「思っていたより全然大丈夫だったわ」という実感にはならないと思うのでこれは仕方ないとして、後者の動力性能については、特にスポーツカーやスポーツセダンを乗り継いできた人には 「百聞は一踏みにしかず」ってやつですかね

    モデル3パフォーマンスに乗り換えた2019年当時、クルマ好きの友人(BMW M3/M4/M5乗りなど)に乗ってもらいましたが、皆さん予想通りの反応をしてくれて楽しかったのを思い出します。

    • HiroHiro

      Hello, Model3 Life!

      「デパートの上にあったパンダの乗り物」笑!!
      ほんと、イメージはそうなのかもしれませんね。

      EVの登場は単に別の新しいカタチの乗り物が登場して、本来は選択肢が広がって喜ばしいことなんですが、
      どういうわけか、頑なにエンジン車じゃないとダメだという人が多くて、??となりますね。
      そういう人こそ、乗ってみると、コロッと変わったりするんですけどね。私みたいに(笑)

      1
  3. beach box

    Hiro

    Thank you for your prompt response.

    いやはや、そんなデータが公表されているとは露知らずで。自分で調べずにイメージだけで語ることの危なさを痛感しました…

    まさに私も初代リーフのイメージがあり、バッテリー寿命についてはネガティブなイメージがありました。しかしバッテリー単体で見てもそれほどまでに性能が維持されるのでしたら、その他の消耗品等も考慮すると世間(自身を含む)のイメージよりも遥かに車としての寿命も長い可能性が高いのでしょうね。勉強になりました。

    私自身、今下駄車としてw204のc200(AMGスポーツパッケージプラスという、なんちゃってAMG仕様です。これがメルセデスらしからぬ脚の硬さで…山に持っていくと案外走るのですが。お二人がどう感じはるか気になります笑)に乗っているのですが、最近、下駄車にガソリンは要らないのかもしれないなと思う機会があります。NAエンジンが好きということもあるのですが、ダウンサイジングターボの初期の車なのでターボラグを感じ、リニアリティに欠けると感じる時がままあります。あと、案外燃費も悪いし。車としてのパッケージングは気に入っているのですけどね。
    そういう意味では、Hiroさんが仰るようにBEVは楽しいのかもしれないなぁと思います。

    長々と脱線してしまいました。改めて、ご教示戴いて有難うございました!

    1